Are Tigers fans backing United?

The whole United/Tiger controversy seems to have gone a bit quiet. Does this mean that all you Tigers fans have accepted United and are ready to to move on and support the new team? Looks to me like promising times ahead with the new lineup which isn't so good for all those who were hoping the United would fail.

Topic #34837 | Report this topic


Tiger Watcher  
Years ago

NO

Reply #481892 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

NO

Reply #481893 | Report this post


Kingston  
Years ago

With the amount of associations they have signed up as partners I think they are feeling pretty good about themselves.

Reply #481894 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

No - I won't be supporting any NBL club.

Reply #481896 | Report this post


Pandora  
Years ago

Kingston can you fill me in what this association partnership is all about

Reply #481899 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

United should take the championship this year then management will be laughing

Reply #481900 | Report this post


The Dream  
Years ago

No

Reply #481905 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Never.

Reply #481912 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Agree with you Kingston, looking forward to getting to as many games as possible and the link with the associations will be great.

Reply #481914 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Nope. I'm waiting for a new Melbourne team and I'll be getting on that bandwagon. In the meantime won't be supporting anyone or going to any NBL games

Reply #481915 | Report this post


paul  
Years ago

The Tigers linked up with quite a few local associations this year and I think the name change to United was designed to get in the door with more associations before they have competition from a second Melbourne team.

Reply #481920 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Melbourne might not get a second team for a long time so you might be missing a lot of NBL

Reply #481921 | Report this post


jonno  
Years ago

Melbourne fans need to ask themselves is it better to have a team with any name eg United or no team at all?

If you want to have a team in the NBL at all, you need to support United or they to will become extinct and if no one supports United why is anyone going to put together a 2nd team in a city that doesnt support the existing team??

Whether you like the name or not, whether you were a Tigers, Dragons, Magic, Giants, Titans, etc supporter i encourage you to get to as many games as you can, they have a awesome roster so you should enjoy the game even if you hate the name, etc. Its the only way any Melbourne team/even the NBL will survive and flourish.

I understand why Tigers fans are angry, i would be annoyed if the 36ers did the same thing, but at the end of the day id still go to games and support the best i can because even a poorly rebranded team is better than no team or NBL at all.

Especially given you guys have a MVP level import with 4 Boomers, its a really good roster, should be entertaining to watch a good mix of shooters, athleticism, versatile players so if your a basketball fan and can get past all the other crap you should enjoy watching this team play and at this early stage id have them fighting Perth for the Title, it will be tough for the 36ers (and most other teams) to put together a roster this good, especially if DJ leaves.

Reply #481923 | Report this post


Tiger Watcher  
Years ago

Big tigers fan and won't be exactly supporting them (Might jump on the 36er's)but at least we still got a team in Melb.

Any less teams and we don't have a comp so hope they thirve which will encourage investors for a 2nd team...hopefully

Reply #481924 | Report this post


Wildcat Fan  
Years ago

Well said Jonno. That's the attitude that is needed. Was going to say something similar. For all everybody knows, the Tigers might have been on their last legs and the owners (as wealthy as they are) might not have stuck around in the long run.

This might be their way of really trying to revive basketball in Melbourne, not just keep plodding along and staying above water.

Reply #481926 | Report this post


Kingston  
Years ago

The second Melbourne group is hardly inspiring.

Reply #481934 | Report this post


skull  
Years ago

the re-branding was terrible and I still don't like it but now think it was the right thing to do...1 step backwards to take 2 steps forward !!

the old Tigers people I talk to (or listen to)these days are stuck in the past & spinning their wheels in the mud.....seems like there was no other way but to break away.

Reply #481935 | Report this post


Rav  
Years ago

At least you guys in Melbourne have a team to support.
Brisbane haven't had a team since the Bullets went belly up in 2008.


Reply #481936 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

the second melbourne team has supposedly been coming the last 2-3 years.. where are they? wheres brisbane?

Melbourne supporters should stop wishing and hoping and get behind the only team they have. The only team in Victoria which has been a main stay from day dot no matter what name they go by.

Melbourne are putting together an extremely positive roster, if they win fans will come.

Reply #481937 | Report this post


Jack Toft  
Years ago

You Tigers fans not jumping on the United bandwagon are more than welcome to barrack for the Sixers when they play in Melbourne. If you ask nicely we might even be able to rustle up some Sixers polos to send over.

Reply #481947 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

The 2nd Melb team will be in the NBL in one more season along with another 3 teams.

Reply #481948 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Johnno the difference is the TIGERS were not going to fold or hadn't folded. It is a greedy business decision to lock out any other competitors taking the fans not following tigers. There is no heart in that kind of management. and shame on the NBL supporting it. THey have pretty much said that super teams are in and look out if other teams from Capital cites get up and running and the demise of the rural teams follow. They will be at risk.. Thank god for councils and supporters who are keeping them going...

There are two sides, the heartfelt supporters and fans that kept the team going while others came and went and now those fans from other teams are riding off the back of the success of the Tigers and the players developed under there lead. I would be furious too if that happened to my NBL team as would anyone else. Imagine it happening to say the 2 QLD teams that were taken over and rolled into a super new Brissy team to support the fans of those defunct teams....and the country teams were left with no support….

THen there is those who just want to go to be entertained and only give a crap about themselves and support a business mans crafty ways to make money and gain power and control… Many I imagine that go to Perth would only be fair weather part time supporters going for entertainment and if the millionaire suddenly stopped the income and the team lost its core and fell to the bottom of the ladder, it would be a different story….

The 2 will never agree…they are two different business and value systems

If the owners truly had heart then they would have created a new team and bring all the non tigers supporters together and left the Tigers alone and leave the players and fans to it. It is also about the players who are now in the modern mindset and really do not have the heart of former players of yesteryear, where the club meant everything…. This is all a sign of our self serving self centred lets convince every we do things for the right reasons when there is always an underlying motive to make money and have the power and cut out the little man.. Its the supermarket powerhouse attitude in society that most have been sucked in to..

Good for you Tigers fans that have not lost your integrity and decide to not support this SCAM. Support and interstate team with your favourite player in the mean time and be amongst loyal fans with their teams to the end, win or lose….

Reply #481950 | Report this post


Jonno  
Years ago

The problem is i doubt the owners have made a cent from the Tigers, infact id be willing to bet they have poored in hundreds of thousands of there money to keep the team going.

Yes they may be mega rich, but they dont have to spend a single cent on the NBL if they dont wish to.

Id say the Tigers would have folded if they didnt make this move to me it was like, 'im sick of losing money under the Tigers model, we just cant get enough support , it doesnt work, lets try something to get more fans engaged to see if we can survive' type of move.

Im not saying they got it right. But these owners are not greedy they have invested far more $$$, time and effort than 99% of fans ever will. If the tigers fan base are as big and strong as people think and supported the club properly moves like this wouldnt have to happen.

I think they stuffed up the re-brand too, but i also think a team under any branding is better than no team, which i think was the alternative in the not too distant future. Its not like people are lining up to poor $$ into NBL clubs, they are not NBA clubs that go up in value and are not in leagues that are backed by huge $$$ from tv.

The things the owners have done right are
1. kept the team alive
2. assembled a championship callibre roster

There are obviously others, but they are 2 key things fans need to appreciate.

My advice to all NBL supporters in Melbourne, Tigers, Dragons, Titans, Giants, Magic, even if you dont like the re-brand, get to as many games as possible, wear your teams colours, pack the place out with Tigers jerseys, refer to the team as the Tigers, even cheer for the other team if you want, but buy a ticket and get along and watch the awesome team they have put together. Its the only way the team and the NBL survives, if you dont there will likely be no Melbourne team and possibly no fully pro basketball league in the country.

If enough of you do that, then another investor might go wow there are really thousands and thousands of Tigers (or what ever team) supporters, lets invest in the NBL and bring them back as the 2nd team. If no one shows up to United games, potential investors are going to be like there is no market for a 2nd NBL team in Melbourne, people just dont buy tickets. That to me is the only way the Tigers have any chance of returning or any 2nd NBL team in Melbourne of existing.

So Tigers fans, buy a ticket, go to the games, deck yourself out in Tigers gear, cheer and chant the Tigers name, even cheer the opposition team if you want, and enjoy watching what really is a awesome roster play the game that we all love at a high and entertaining level.

Reply #481959 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

Anonymous it is a shame you didn't add a name so people can refer to your post.

I will simply address this to "the most recent Anonymous"

You point to the 'what if' scenario of Queensland teams being rolled into one.. well that situation is not what is happening here.. there was only ONE Melbourne team currently playing and for the moment their remains only one. No one has lost anything in number of teams that wasn't lost many years ago now.

You call the decision to change names a "Greedy business decision" and "the team wasn't going to fold".. Yes, true.. but the team wasn't exactly thriving now was it? Its image.. whilst has history is one that is now tired, old.. and unappealing to the masses.. In the end this is a BUSINESS decision, should the owners (albeit millionaire owners) keep pumping their money into what is essentially a business enterprise that is not actually bringing them any real returns all because of some allegiance to a NAME of all things? Why shouldn't they try to appeal to other demographics? The 'Tigers' brand.. whilst recognisable was a relatively small niche market, a niche market that indeed would be infringed upon once more Melbourne teams pop up..

As for the 'Rural' teams you worry about.. lets be honest.. they are straggling and to some extent holding the league back. Townsville will now be playing out of a glorified local RSL, Cairns crowds haven't been great, Wollongong is barely floating along.. if major cities generate the money and leave the rural teams in the dust maybe we should stop fighting evolution and pandering to the weak? Evolution is survival of the fittest and sometimes weaklings die off... sad but true fact of the matter. The league can either forever stay a struggling bush league or it can try to generate some of that selfish MONEY you hate so much and actually try to go places!

In the end.. a change needed to be made. It is a shame for the 'old boys club' they can't sit at a Tigers game for free and reminisce about the days of old.. but the fact is, things change.. Tigers had their run in the sun and people aren't about to forget about the club that gave us Andrew Gaze.

Either way, I find your argument idiotic. These teams are not a charity.. they hope to atleast break even or do better. If you want the league to have the money to bring in great players, more teams etc.. you need to back the occasional leap of faith and the occasional need to put an old dog to sleep so that a young pup can take its place.

I don't like the name 'United' but I understand why they are doing what they are doing... a few wins and an exciting import and things look a lot brighter in Melbourne all of a sudden.

Reply #481961 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Bait taken and now the real passion for a United Melbourne starts.. Excellent Smithers, Excellent...…..

Reply #481969 | Report this post


paul  
Years ago

GWB, they are doing what they're doing to get a competitive advantage over the team the NBL wants to bring in in a year's time.

It seems like they are basically trying to sabotage the NBL's expansion in Melbourne. I won't support that sort of strategy.

Reply #481972 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Agree with you Paul. It is all about blocking out competition. Melbourne should be able to support 2 teams. Yes Tigers needed a revamp, but it had viability with the right support.

Reply #481978 | Report this post


paul  
Years ago

There is certainly savviness about what they're doing, they're no fools, it will come down to whether it's too clever by half - ie turns off more people than it attracts.

What I don't like about it is it's in clear opposition to the NBL's publicly stated aim of expansion, and that has shades of the 2000s where rich owners just did what they wanted.

Add that to how poorly members/supporters were treated with the announcement out of the blue and I find it hard to get enthusiastic about this new club.

Reply #481984 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

There needs to be 2 teams in Melbourne to create rivalry, provide local competition for product and an alternative.

If United effectively canvas the entire metro feeder base it will roadblock a new team.

It would have been far better to launch 2 new entities at the same time rather than the way its gone down which effectively could make it near on impossible now for a second team to gain any traction.

Reply #481985 | Report this post


Bear  
Years ago

Speaking as a fan of the NBL and one who would go to a rival game between the Dragons and Tigers in the not so old days, I am still waiting for some kind of inspired rivalry to provide me with inspiration and incentive to go back and watch live NBL games in Melbourne.

Should the Tigers have stayed and re branded maybe as Victoria, not Melbourne or changed as they have done is not the big issue any longer, it is, how will we get what the public want now?

We want some rivalry, here in Melbourne/Victoria!

Will United and their strategy kill off a rival bid, and if they do, then I am affraid they have killed off the NBL in Victoria, for me anyway...

Reply #481988 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I've been a tigers supporter for 25 years and I won't be supporting United. I would rather not have a team than follow them.

The best thing for basketball in Melbourne would have been for the tigers to remain (as they've been the only Victorian club able to over the years) and for a new Melbourne team to join which could represent the other clubs.

As it is now, there will be many tigers supporters who won't follow United and you'll have a lot of other supporters not following United as they'll still see them as the tigers.

Reply #481990 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

how would the United club kill off any potential new club?

Reply #481995 | Report this post


skull  
Years ago

^that was me

Reply #481996 | Report this post


jonno  
Years ago

Paul, maybe its just me, i actually think this could be an opportunity for a Tigers re-launch in a year or 2 as the 2nd Melbourne team, if a potential investor buys the Tigers brand.

I was a subscriber to the 'conspiracy theory' that was posted on here, basically this being a way of re-invigerating the Tigers and the Melbourne rilvary by taking them away temporarily and having them bought back by a savoir, then tigers fans would have there team and would hate United who stole there team, non tigers fans also have a team. If it happens it could work.

But for that to happen they would have to be sure that there is heaps of Tigers supporters, who would actually go to games and support the team financially, so the best way to do that is go to United games in a Tigers jersey and chant the Tigers name. It could give them the best of both worlds. As i say the Tigers were not supported well enough to be viable and hence why the United move was made, i reckon that would be more of a factor than blocking competition, usually when you have 2 strong teams in a region, if there genuinely is enough support the crowds go up for both not down so why would the owners want to block that. If 2 teams cant survive in Melbourne there just isnt enough fans willing to support financially, eg buy tickets, and if thats the case then there is no point having 2 teams.

I almost guarantee if the Tigers were viable as they were, then this move wouldnt have happened, so its upto the fans to get behind there teams and support them so they dont have to make moves like this.

Reply #481997 | Report this post


skull  
Years ago

^here here

Reply #481998 | Report this post


Thunder Jam  
Years ago

As for the 'Rural' teams you worry about.. lets be honest.. they are straggling and to some extent holding the league back. Townsville will now be playing out of a glorified local RSL, Cairns crowds haven't been great, Wollongong is barely floating along.. if major cities generate the money and leave the rural teams in the dust maybe we should stop fighting evolution and pandering to the weak?


What a naive statement!
Check out Cairns crowds vs Tigers numbers!

Reply #482000 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

"...leave the rural teams in the dust maybe we should stop fighting evolution and pandering to the weak?"

Not sure a 4 team competition would be all that interesting, or profitable for those major city teams that are left.

Reply #482008 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Was reading something the other day about Melbourne United picking up a few soccer fans because of their name.

Reply #482010 | Report this post


Jodiechrist  
Years ago

I'm not backing United, not at all.

Here's some reasons why -

1) Tigers fans have been treated appallingly throughout this entire process. No consultation, and then a boring tirade of mixed messages of "no no, it's still the Tigers, we're doing this to survive - this is definitely still your club" followed by "Become a founding member of Melbourne United!". If it's not a new club, then how in the hell would members of 20+ years suddenly become founding members in the year 2014? If they had been open about this from the start, I would have a lot more sympathy.

2) Tigers have survived for a very long time, through some absolutely appalling management (and rosters) over the years. To get rid of Tigers after their first promising season in a very long time, where we had good results and a good roster, as well as a very good run of sell out crowds, is ludicrous. Which brings me to ...

3) The owners had no intention of trying to keep, let alone save the Tigers. The name Melbourne United has been registered for a very long time (over 18 months prior to the announcement, from memory?), and as a result of this early decision, they also declined many opportunities to capitalise from the success of the last season. I'd been wondering why we could get early bird membership sign ups at the last home game (as we had been able to do in previous years), why basic merch hadn't been restocked all season, and why easy sales like the heritage round single hadn't even been considered. Because they knew there would be no more Tigers at the end of the season.

4) Which, makes it even worse that all of us long term fans (and short term - doesn't matter, a fan is a fan) weren't even given the chance to say goodbye to the team we've supported for so long - we just get knocked for six by a random announcement during the off season. That too could have been handled better, by commiserating the end of an era and introducing a new era altogether.

5) Aside from being damaging to Tigers fans, I think this move is detrimental to Basketball in Melbourne at the very least, and the NBL as a whole. This attempt to mesh all prior basketball brands under one banner, making blatant appeals and claims to the history of Titans, Dragons, Magic & Giants is a obvious attempt to corner the nostalgic basketball market (which history has shown to be fairweather at best), and then to capture the state, ahead of the introduction of a second Melbourne team next year. This isn't increasing the chances of a home town rivalry, which Melburnians absolutely love, instead it's trying to obliterate the chances of a competing team remaining viable enough to even become a good rival in the first place. My hope is that enough ex-Tigers fans and other sensible people are willing to support the second team when it emerges and give it a real chance.

6) I don't have to support a Melbourne team, particularly one that I believe is shooting Melbourne basketball in the foot, in order to support the NBL. I will be keeping a closer eye on the other teams I'm fond of, and will support the Crocs for this season. This doesn't translate into stadium tickets, but it does mean I continue to consume the sport by whatever media is offered, kick a bit of money into the Crocs, and keep the conversation happening locally with those around me. I'm also taking a much stronger interest in SEABL. Regardless of this, to suggest that Tigers fans, after being screwed like this, have a responsibility to uphold to their city and the NBL who has allowed this to happen, is ludicrous. United is the team that's damaged and jeopardised this relationship, not Tigers fans.

Reply #482159 | Report this post




You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.



Close ads
Serio: Tourism photography and videography
Little Streaks - The fun and interactive good-habits app designed especially for kids.

Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.

Recent Posts



.


An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 11:49 pm, Fri 29 Mar 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754