Gee wow anon, really disturbs us that does.

Take your kiddy politics elsewhere!

To point out the obvious, there is no such thing as a member club any more.

Interesting point...I wonder that with the disbanding of the old BASA and that the old constitution has been thrown out the window, and that anything goes at the moment and old rules and regulations no longer apply. Would be interested if someone "in the know" could answer the question, it makes it a very interesting scenario then for the pro/rel debate if there are no regulations to be adhered to, can BSA make them up as they go along?

There are no foundation clubs of BSA, so how can they have 'rights'?

I saw that Western Magic and one other club (Norwood? I can't remember, and the results are gone from Sporting Pulse) totally dominated the 6-team Div 2 summer comp. Both the Magic and the other team won their semi-finals by huge margins. It wouldn't make sense to leave them in Div 1 after that.

Western Magic should NOT have a div 1 team anywhere regardless. They are not a BSA member club, they do not field an ABA team. If any Magic players wanna piece of div 1, they should be playing for Woodville or West.

Any club with a team good enough for Div 1 should have the chance to have their team play at that level. That's why it is imperative pro/rel is implemented.
If it works in Vic, then it can work here.

Agree with LC here,

a) No such thing as a member club any more.

b) If any club, such as Western Magic or Torrens Valley are good enough to play div 1, why not.

If clubs want to get these kids then they need to engage a development officer and have them out and about.

Right now Magic are bigger than Eastern and Centrals. If they don't get their act together why should they be guarenteed a spot in div 1.

"Thats it, poach all the talent..."

Ha ha ha, think about what your saying!

It's under 10's, far out!
I know the little guys that play and they are awesome and deserve to be in div 1.
Quit complaining just coz u have some competition that happens to be Western Magic, who everyone seems to hate.
It's basketball.
It shouldn't have this many issues.

#13 =]

most interesting that now magic want div 1 teams when the reason the majority left woodville was that div 1 and 2 was too hard or wanted to play at there level rather than develop as a club or are some of your memories too short

now bleating out to be div 1 - my how the worm has turned -

Eastern was never a member club, but they play div1
Eastern do not devlop players, they poach, go look at their aba team,oh and the coaches as well, look at how many under 10 teams they have.
Magic deserve a spot in div 1 over Eastern.
They have more teams
They develop
I was against Magic at first, but I think the club has put the wind up woodville and woodville are getting better because of it
"competition is the word"
We cannot have two country clubs in the comp, we have forestville. Magic in Eastern out

OOPS, I was laughing so hard I hit the enter without entering anything....LOL...chuckle, LOL

Explain to me how magic have taken players from other clubs to enter under 10 teams......they must have people at the woodville training sessions.
I argument is Magic versus Eastern, who has more teams, who has under 10 teams

We haven't taken any players they come to us coz they don't like their old club. I talk to the people that come to magic and they didn't get taken by us, they wanted to play for us. same thing goes for the coaches we dont 'take them' its their choice.

We have developed plenty of players, how would you know that we haven't? I used to play for Magic when we we're social and I have come so far being in district with magic, my skills have increaed MASSIVELY. Just coz you can't take it doesn't mean you get to diss us.

Stop complaining becuase we have a div 1 team and it's possible for us to have more. If our teams have the skills to be in div 1 then they should be in div 1. It's simple.

#13 :]
I e Western Magic =]

It didn't come up but there was a love hear there.
I <3 Western Magic

SO where did they come from Mars ??
check previous club played history #13 - fact not fiction