Isaac
Years ago

BA: Sydney Spirit name OK

A disappointing decision, in my opinion, from Basketball Australia in almost endorsing the Sydney Spirit name choice for the former Razorbacks NBL club. WNBL team Bendigo Spirit had complained after having used the name for one full season already before West Sydney adopted the nickname with no awareness that it was already in use by a WNBL team.

Derwin mentions trademarks but it's the 'whole vibe of the thing' - what faith can you put in an NBL club who don't even keep a cursory eye on their partner league to think "wait, the name seems familiar, let's keep brainstorming"!? Plus their logo is embarrassing for the league.

This from the Bendigo Advertiser:

The Bendigo Spirit's fight to keep its name exclusively has fallen on deaf ears after the Sydney Spirit were yesterday given the green light to use the name.

Basketball Australia chief executive officer Scott Derwin released a statement yesterday afternoon on behalf of the interim board of Basketball which had investigated the controversy surrounding Sydney's use of the Spirit name.

''While the Board was sympathetic to Bendigo's objection, given it had not been made aware of Sydney's application to use the Spirit name, it has rejected Bendigo's contention that it would have a negative impact on the team's brand commercially,'' the statement said.

''Bendigo Spirit has cited in its objections the case with the Wildcats as a precedent set by the WNBL, which rejected a name proposed by Christchurch based on the grounds that an NBL team in Perth was operating under the same Wildcats name. It is important to understand that this was in fact based on a legal decision, as the Perth Wildcats had trademarked its name.

''As Bendigo had not registered Spirit as its intellectual property, it has been found that Sydney went through the correct process and received the requisite approvals and initiated the change in its team name in good faith.

More from the Bendigo Advertiser

Topic #16846 | Report this topic


Kent Brockman  
Years ago

Just shows how bad relationships in Baketball are in Australia.

Could you imagine another business stealing one of its partners names / identity and not thinking that there is a problem?

Reply #198197 | Report this post


ANON12  
Years ago

IMO the new BA/NBL Board (or whatever they want to be called) do not seem interested in taking the WNBL seriously. I would be interested to see Lorraine Landon's comments on the decision (unless she has been gagged) after the amount of time and energy she has put in to promoting the WNBL. This seems a strange decision given the fact that the WNBL markets itself better than the NBL with a major sponsor and free to air TV. Possibly Bendigo will not take any legal action because it would be too expensive.
Seems a shame, but then who isn't surprised with some of the decisions that emanate from the BA/NBL front office.

Reply #198200 | Report this post


DD  
Years ago

Not the best start-up PR for the new club is it...

1. The name is laim anyway
2. Everyone out of the 'know' thinks its a new A-League or netball team out of Sydney.
3. Its already taken... by a basketball club in a national league...?

Reply #198201 | Report this post


MH  
Years ago

Yes the name is lame but now the cheer leaders can definitely use "Spirit Fingers" in their performances.

Reply #198204 | Report this post


Cat 15  
Years ago

The imports will probably get to use plenty of spirit fingers while they're here as well!

Reply #198218 | Report this post


twenty four  
Years ago

I still want to know who the fools that picked the name were, and who decided to keep it, even after the negative responses....

Reply #198262 | Report this post


Double Standards  
Years ago

Didn't the Wildcats kick up a stink when Christchurch wanted to use their name and BA/NBL said no?

Double standards here!

Reply #198300 | Report this post


DJ  
Years ago

The problem is Sydney Spirit have done everything legally right to obtain/register the name. Therefore BA and the NBL even if they rules the name is Bendigo's and Sydney can't use it Sydney would win in a court of law if they wanted to take it that far and BA would have known it was fighting a losing battle no matter what they thought was right.

I think it's ludicrous and Sydney Spirit should have automatically renegged and issued an apology as soon it became public knowledge that the name already existed elsewhere but nobody likes to admit being wrong.

I can only see it hurting sydney and their current stage that basketball in sydney and as a team. And all this will only further impact negatively on the NBL.

Reply #198302 | Report this post


Isaac  
Years ago

Double Standards - read the article and note the mention of a trademark applying in that Wildcats case.

This is "One Basketball" - it should not get to this. Sydney should have absolutely withdrawn and rebranded.

Reply #198306 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

These clowns are going to be lucky to limp the NBL through just one more season.

Reply #198308 | Report this post


Double Standards  
Years ago

"These clowns are going to be lucky to limp the NBL through just one more season."

Maybe BA were prepared to let this through keeping in the back of their minds that after the season the team could be booted with the imminent reform changes.

Reply #198312 | Report this post


DD  
Years ago

Forget that the Sydnet crew 'went through the right channels' to aquire the name.... WHY THE HELL DID THEY WANT THE NAME 'SPIRIT?!?!?!?!'

This is rediculous...

Reply #198321 | Report this post


FM  
Years ago

That is so weak by BA. Just shows that not only do they have no idea on Basketball they have no idea on anything else either.

Reply #198326 | Report this post


Qlder  
Years ago

So what are the colours of this mob?

Reply #198330 | Report this post




You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.



Close ads
Little Streaks - The fun and interactive good-habits app designed especially for kids.
Serio: Tourism photography and videography

Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.

Recent Posts



.


An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 11:50 am, Sat 20 Apr 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754