Jason
Years ago
So the 6ers beat Perth in 2 out of the 3 games they've played this season - losing only in overtime - and Perth get the Catallini Cup.
Sounds a bit backwards to me
Wildcat Fan
Years ago
The Sixers and Wildcats nominate 1 game (out of the 4 regular season games) to contest the Cattalini Cup. They nominated yesterdays game as the one to do it.
I agree though, it does seem a bit backward - but im not really a fan of meaningless in-season trophy games anyway. It over-glorifies it a bit, and does anyone really care??
Thats not a knock on Cattalini or Rogers though - Both are champion players for both clubs.
Why not have the cup go to the team that wins the season series against each other? Awarded at the last match up between the teams.
Isaac
Years ago
Putting it on a single game avoids a situation where it's a draw. e.g., 2-2 and same points differential. Also means they can alternate presentations and know exactly when it's going to be awarded, so Cat can put on his best shorts and polo in advance.
EC
Years ago
I don't agree Isaac, a draw, i.e each team win 2 games each, can be decided by the tally of points. Its very unlikely that 4 games are going to result in 2 wins each and exactly the same points each. If it did happen, it could be decided on the highest number of rebounds, the least turnovers, the player who has the highest personal score etc. There are many ways to skin a cat. Its stupid that these 2 teams play each other 4 times and yet the cup is awarded based on 1 only game. I didn't stay back after the game yesterday so I missed it, but now I am glad I did miss it because it would have been annoying. Salt to the wound created by the loss.
XY
Years ago
Do as they do in cricket - a series tie sees the cup retained with the last winning team.
Isaac
Years ago
How do you alternate presentations without making the schedule more difficult than the league obviously already finds it? This way they can also work it around Cat and Rogey. Less fuss, given there are other things the clubs can worry about more.
It's a cup named for a guy who played five years here, with an accompanying medal named for a guy who played two years in Adelaide. Until recently, the event didn't even exist. I'm surprised people care that much how it's awarded. It's just a little thing to create some media interest, maybe encourage people to attend.
Cat would've been in black tie otherwise...
alexkrad
Years ago
I played against Cattalini tonight in a local B grade league.. He isnt as tall as I thought.
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 2:50 am, Thu 25 Apr 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754
