Anonymous
Years ago

Ben Simmons to miss U19 World Champs

Will be preparing for LSU.

Bummer :-(

Topic #36487 | Report this topic


Curtley  
Years ago

Not because his minder won't let him.

Reply #515243 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

I think he is past the junior tournys now anyways. He is clearly ready for the real thing.

Reply #515244 | Report this post


Darryl  
Years ago

Is a man amongst boys already. Only 16 months away from being high lottery pick

Reply #515247 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

There goes any medal chances...

What about Adel, bolden, McVeigh and Humphries?

Reply #515254 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Doesn't sound like he will be available for the Boomers V NZ in August either, which is a real shame

Reply #515255 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

"There goes any medal chances"

I don't think that is right at all.

We lost the Gold medal game in the U17's by just 7 points without Simmons.

Humphries had an average game against the USA too.

So add McVeigh to last tournaments team and we should be right up there again

Reply #515256 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Shame, but understand he needs to make tough decisions. Feels like he will be more committed as an adult than Bogut though, which I guess is not saying a lot.

Reply #515260 | Report this post


Kobe24  
Years ago

Thats a bit unfair in Bogut, he has had some pretty tough long winded injuries throughout his career. Think about how many USA guys have simply been unavailable for service, and haven't had injuries, luckily they have the talent to cover but some of the best haven't been keen.

Right cal for Simmons, as someone said before, he is under 2 years away from a high draft selection. Big picture is a so much more important for him and hopefully country too come Olympic time.

Reply #515265 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Not unfair for Bogut at all, he's a talker.

Reply #515266 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Bogut played 04,06,08, injured '10 with elbow. So he has missed one Olympic campaign.
Recovering from ankle surgery last campaign also.
He takes those spots and can't go I'm sure you'll label him selfish for not giving up his spot for a young kid.
Also played in u19's, won a GOLD MEDAL AND MVP (beast mode).
Yeah what a talker.....

Reply #515272 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

What has he done at worlds and Olympics?

Reply #515281 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

Pfft "What has he done at worlds or olympics"

A lot more than you!

Just because he hasn't brought home a medal doesn't mean he hasn't played well. And I think Bogut wanting to play for Australia is genuine. He said well before the last world cup that it was 50/50. But he said he has always been adamant on the Rio Olympics and the qualifying series and that hasn't changed. Give the guy a chance FFS now that he isn't injured.

Reply #515284 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Time will tell ffs

Reply #515285 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

What a traitor...

Reply #515293 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Sorry but if Simmons can't take the time to play for his country at this age then he's really not worthy of a spot when older. Come on get real he's preparing for college, which does not start till after un19 worlds, in what way is that going to compromise his chances of an NBA draft pick in a couple of years. The Americans who will be p,acing at un19 worlds will certainly be going AND still getting ready for college, does Simmons think he's too good to p,at in his age group? Perhaps the Americans can show him he's not quite there YET.

Reply #515300 | Report this post


Kobe24  
Years ago

Anonymous thats about as stupid as it gets, that first sentence of your last post!

Reply #515314 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

^ Don't agree that he's 'not worth a spot when he's older.' Plenty of people make ordinary decisions at the age of 17 and I don't think we'd all want to be punished for those for the rest of our lives.

Pretty hypocritical for people who want to rag on Maker and then give Simmons a pass, though. Plenty of American kids get on college campuses as early as they can and start preparing, but it's becoming standard practice for the best of them to take the time to represent their country when the opportunity presents itself.

Reply #515318 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Exactly, and that's what I meant, why should a player who turns their nose up to represent their country get another opportunity, and at 17 if he's old enough to make the decisions where to play he's old enough to understand that it's a pri algae to represent your country not a RIGHT and lots of players would give up a lot to do so. Smacks of arrogance in my books.
Maker is a different case, he's NOT really Australian

Reply #515322 | Report this post


Kobe24  
Years ago

He's a kid, when he is playing Olympics in years to come, everyone will be happy. Silly to ridicule over a u19's. Wreaks of tall poppy syndrome for mine. I say get fresh physically and mentally for college, you'll be there for 1 season, then time to represent Australia year to year game to game in the biggest and best league in the world. Lets be thankful that he is so skilful and calls Aus home!

Reply #515325 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Sucks simmons and maker aren't gonna be there....
Personally I don't think Adel will play either.

That leaves vasljevic, Wilson, krebs, Clark, McVeigh, Noi, froling, Humphries, perry amongst others. Maybe blagojevic, white and hunter For the rest.

Reply #515331 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

LOL. Shouldn't be allowed to play when hes older? We are talking about the best player in the world of his age group here. Who cares if he does or doesn't play under 19s? We have won medals in the U19 tournys and what has it done for Basketball in Australia? very little. Its the senior medals that matter.

Reply #515383 | Report this post


Kobe24  
Years ago

GWB, I know right, just such an irrational over reaction!

Reply #515397 | Report this post


Sting What?  
Years ago

I can confirm Deng Adel is playing. He is in Canberra at the moment preparing for the world champs.

Thon Maker has previously said in interviews that he would love to represent Australia but the timing with studies and expenses to travel for trainings to prepare with the team doesn't fit in with his schedule. He doesn't want to rock up to WC without even knowing his team mates and having no chemistry.

I assume that is the same with Ben Simmons too, he can't be in Australia for the whole preparation and has bigger fish to fry at the moment with college coming up.

Got to remember these kids are still amateurs and not getting paid yet. Wait til they are pro. The future for Australian Basketball is extremely bright.

Reply #515398 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Thanks sting, can you tell us who else might make the team?

Reply #515401 | Report this post


Curtley  
Years ago

Maker is as Australian as Russell Crowe; born overseas and made his name in the USA.

Reply #515411 | Report this post


Sting What?  
Years ago

Don't know of anyone else in the team Anon. I just know that Deng Adel is there as I am affiliated with his junior club Longhorns.

Reply #515419 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Spot on comparison about crowe haha

Reply #515437 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Spot on comparison about crowe haha

Reply #515438 | Report this post


Benno  
Years ago

No Thon Maker doesn't want to play because he'll be exposed at how shit he actually is!

Reply #515445 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Some unbelievable posts above

All I will say is Dante Exum.

2012 - Played U17 Worlds - Aus Silver Medal
2013 - Played U19 Worlds - Aus came fourth
2014 - NBA Draft pick Number 5

I'm sure Ben and his family know the story.

Considering what Dante did, some of the comments above don't add up to me.

Reply #515474 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

All I think U19 matters for, is stitching up players to be Australian reps for the future. Guys like Deng Adel who werent born here and could claim citizenship elsewhere. We have had gold medals at the u19, it has meant nothing and the success hasn't translated. I wouldn't be getting in a huff about the kid missing it. We all like to beast in every competition we enter, but we just need to realise this competition isn't the biggest thing going on for some of these kids. Playing one decent college season will do more for Ben than a solid U19 world cup showing. It will do more for his game too. Dante didn't play college and look at the learning curve he has to make? I know its not a matter of "one or the other" for ben, but he should concentrate on what matters.

Reply #515479 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Well if they can't make the ONE camp which is what they will have for selection, which is actually during the college summer break, and then spend a couple of weeks at a per world and then worlds tournament also during the summer Hols in America is says a lot really. You can make all the excuses you like but it's poor form, or arrogance take your pick

Reply #515581 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Still sulking about being cut for the Worlds?

Reply #515593 | Report this post


billy holye  
Years ago

More to the point you don't go back in life to go fwd the progression for all our young players is juniors then you progress to seniors. Ben Simmons is already in the senior program playing U19 does not make much sense in terms of progression....his decision opens the door for the development of other young players who would have been playing behind Simmons or perhaps not even made the team...

Reply #515638 | Report this post


Alpha  
Years ago

As most of the time, the article written by Olgun is poorly written, fairly misleading and he needs to start doing his due diligence. Prob could start with some journalism classes to learn how to establish the facts first. Obviously he is a huge fan of Ben's, but did him no favors.

The only reason for Ben to go to LSU so early would be to attend summer school to improve his academics. NCAA is highly traditional and adamant not to allow anyone to enter the College system without meeting academic requirements. So when it comes to decision making and career prospects, the choice is obvious. Good luck to him.

Reply #515647 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Billy Hoyle hate to point it out BUT . Ben Simmons is in 'high school' he's not YET in the senior ranks. He's NOT a boomer so UN19 EMUS is where he should be
Get the big tags off these kids and let them become adults when they are ready then they hopefully won't get over inflated egos.

Reply #515659 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Some of our talented young guys have succumbed to the hype machine bullshit generated by the US High School/College system.

An entourage of close advisers, overbearing parental control. AIS used to be able to control a lot of this, not any more.

Reply #515665 | Report this post


billy holye  
Years ago

Pretty sure Ben Simmons played for the boomers in the series against NZ 2 years ago as a 17 year old....unless that Boomers team is not really the Boomers? And unless I'm mistaken he also was part of the final Boomers squad chosen to represent Australia at the FIBA World Cup....if he is not part of the senior program already that is terribly misleading....

Reply #515669 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Billy, your recollection is correct. But should NBA guys who can't get a run not play in the D-leauge? Should NBL bench-warmers not play SEABL? Simmons might have been part of the senior program, but all that did was show that he's not ready for that level of competition just yet. And don't you think that maybe the other guys in the u19 team would benefit from playing with him? Didn't Exum attend a Boomers camp prior to starring at u17 Worlds?

Reply #515673 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Yes he may well have been included in the group, but was not and probably will not be part of final selection , SO to poi t out the obvious, he is still in high school, he is STILL quite able to compete at a world tournament for HIS age group, while he waits for his time to come. As do all the others who will be p,ahi g worlds. I'm quite sure if it's good enough for the Americans who are ranked the best in the world in ALL ages and genders, then a young 18yr old from Australia can also play without jeopardising his chance of selection to the senior ranks or his prep for college.

Reply #515687 | Report this post


billy holye  
Years ago

Man how silly of me I forgot this was the Boomers and Australian basketball where we would rather take an un-athletic "experienced" team to get beaten at the world cup rather than some young guys with potential and we would rather play NBL guys over top 5 NBA Draft picks (in the end we had an awful result probably same result with young guys).
This kid who is unanimously regarded as not only the best high school player in the US but the best 18 year old in the world...who if there was not a 1 year college rule would be in the 2015 NBA draft and some would say would be another top 5 pick.
Oh yeah of course you want that guy to play U19 so that australia can look like we have our stuff together and win a medal and pat ourselves on the back and say "look at our talent coming through"....we wouldn't want to instead fly that kid back to work out with other boomers and get him ready for the Olympics or fly the FULL TIME Boomers coach over to the US to work with him...my question is if he already averaging 28 ppg 12rpg against the America kids who everyone considers the best how does coming home for an U19 camp to compete against other Aussies for 2 weeks and then play in a tournament where he may play against the USA 1 time benfit this kid? he will already be competing against the best US players 2 times this month in NIKE world game and All American game.
If it's all about representing his country he has already done that.

Reply #515720 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

When has he represented his country......he's represented himself, you sound more like his parent or agent lol.
As always just like any comp, you don't have all your best p,ayers in the one team so too the American high school system, so he may be getting 28points playing against his own age and younger, put him up against a whole group of players who are also the strongest individually in their respective high school teams and you may find it different story, ....you may not but if he doesn't do it then you'll never know.

Reply #515749 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

What's the 1 yr college rule as it didn't apply to Exum did it?

Reply #515751 | Report this post


billy hoyle  
Years ago

"When has he represented his country......he's represented himself"

yeah he played U17s when they won Silver and played with the Boomers in the NZ series to qualify for the World Cup.

"put him up against a whole group of players who are also the strongest individually in their respective high school teams and you may find it different story"

that is exactly what he will be doing when he plays for the World Nike Team vs USA and at the McDonalds All American game which is exactly to my point why would he play U19s to get that elite competition 1 time vs the USA when he can go to college for the summer and work out with his team mates and play against NBA pros who come back to LSU to work out....

The 1 year college rule applies to players who compete in the US high school system bc of the time between leaving high school and the draft is not sufficient. Dante never went to US high school so rule doesnt apply as far as i know

Reply #515755 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

I really can't believe what I am reading. People get really uptight about the decisions of other people. It's under 19s. The guy has said, and shown, that he will be playing for the Boomers in future. Who really cares about Under 19? We will probably get a medal in the tournament and no one except the absolute Basketball die hard will even be aware that it happened.

Reply #515759 | Report this post


billy hoyle  
Years ago

GWB well said....Thank You!!!

Reply #515771 | Report this post


Anon  
Years ago

"put him up against a whole group of players who are also the strongest individually in their respective high school teams and you may find it different story"

My recollection was that Ben was voted the best player at the top 100 camp that was held in the USA last year.

That was against the top 100 USA invited High School players in the country. I think that answers your uneducated query above!!!

Reply #515853 | Report this post


LeCan  
Years ago

I can see both sides of people's opinions but the big thing for me is when players are happy to receive a leg up from Basketball Australia or the CoE and then when they're asked to give back refuse to do so. I'm not saying Simmons is doing that directly as I'm pretty sure he went to the states instead of accepting an offer to the CoE, but he has also received benefits associated with Aussie basketball programs which would have assisted greatly with his development.

In saying that, we're all on the outside looking in. As for the Sudanese kid, I don't think he'll pull on the green and gold ever.

Reply #515985 | Report this post


rjd  
Years ago

Disappointed also because he will lose the experience of an important knockout tournament over a short period, which is what the Boomers will encounter when they play WCs and Olympics. He played under 17s as a 16 year-old, so he should have an idea, but U19s is when things start to get serious. Also would've been great if Simmons could come close to what Bogut achieved.

I also hope the decision is not motivated by an effort to evade scrutiny and competition, as people have suggested about Maker.

Reply #516036 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Should be there... A Test against the most elite competition in his age group!
What is he going to be doing? Shooting some free throws at Lsu...

Reply #516037 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Poor performances against world class opponents would have reduced his rep.
Instead he goes to lsu, performs well against ok college teams (some good teams-Kentucky).
After one season, boom they take him in the draft based on potential. if he sucks at worlds, he probably wouldn't be a guaranteed top 5 pick, which might even cause him to stay a another one or two more years in college to reestablish his reputation. Avoiding poor performances against other potential draftees at worlds means you can't question him On he's capablity of competing against the best players until his actually in the nba. By that time his made bank, multi year 5 mil plus a season and endorsements. Later round guys getting much much less and no guarantee.

Reply #516038 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I'd say above post is probably spot on

Reply #516040 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Yeah not really, anyone suggesting he's not going to protect his reputation hasn't been following him the past couple of years.

Reply #516054 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

He's playing high school basketball

Reply #516073 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

It's obvious he's priortitzing himself over the world champs and repping oz. people here are so far up on their high horses that they fail to realize there's absolutely nothing wrong with doing that!

Reply #516082 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

#516082

There isn't anything wrong with that? Really? Bewdy! The future with the Me - generation. And the argument that it gives others the opportunity doesn't wash with me. Whether it's World Champs, Olympic Games, even the old Commonwealth Games I thought we wanted our best out there - barring injury or a bloody good reason - every single time.

Seems like Simmons given a lot of leeway on this issue whereas Maker was bagged out.

Reply #516096 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

And big Humphries not exactly committed yet either:

http://zagsblog.com/articles/recruiting-rundown-nba-scouts-turn-out-to-watch-talent-at-basketball-borders/

Reply #516104 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

The narrow-mindedness of some people on here is ridiculous.

Remember that these guy are KIDS!

Simmons is a one-and-done player, what if he wants to be at LSU a bit longer since he only has one year there - make the most out of his time there. He'll have plenty of time to play for Australia, let the kid make the decision that he feels is best for him.

And for this guy calling out Humphries ^ - What if he wants to play AAU basketball for the one and only time he's able to in his life? What if he has a gruelling high school season and needs to take some time away from basketball?

I understand everyone feels that these kids HAVE to play for their country, otherwise they're traitors - but unless they come out and explicitly say that they're not playing because they 'just don't want to' then leave it.

Go back to your lives and they'll continue to live theirs.

Reply #516110 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Wow. Touchy. Every one to their own opinion, doesn't mean it has to match yours. And "narrow minded"? Please! Seems some on hoops only interested in the same viewpoint.

Reply #516117 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I think it's more that people just need to chill.

Don't have a viewpoint that's based on your own assumptions and speculation, because it's probably not true

Reply #516132 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I don't feel like I should have to join the army and fight the war in Afghanistan because I took advantage of a public school education.

I have my own family and career to manage and take care of without worrying about representing my country.

Basketball isn't an amateur sport where competing for your country at major events is the be all and end all.

Simmons and Humphries should be doing everything right now to improve or protect their nba draft stock. Once they sign a guaranteed nba contract and insurance takes care of any potential disasters while wearing the green and gold they should take pride in representing their country at a senior level and a major championship event if they are selected.

Reply #516139 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Reply #516096

wow.. how self righteous and selfless can someone be? What exactly is your argument? is it that some 17-18 year old kid owes something to Australia in the way of represeting us in a game of basketball? Otherwise he's ungrateful and should never play for Australia again?

sounds like the "me generation?" is speaking up in you!

Reply #516142 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

#516132

I'm pretty chilled actually. What else is a viewpoint if it aint your opinion or point of view? How dumb can I be? What was I thinking? Having my own opinion ....

Reply #516149 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Reply #516155 | Report this post


sircreate  
Years ago


While like most of us Im disappointed that Ben Simmons isnt going to be available for the u19's Worlds, Id like to point out a couple things in his defense as someone whose been keeping an eye on his high school career.

Anyone who say's he's scared about being shown up at the World's is completely ignorant of the facts. His high school team play's one of the most competitive schedules in high school ball. He's regularly playing ranked teams and facing top tier talent.. at the recent Hoop Hall classic he faced 2 top 10 players in the front court Chase Jeter(duke commit) and Stephen Zimmerman(Kentucky, Kansas, Arizona etc chasing him) and he dropped 36pts. He's a McDonalds All American, he was the max preps Junior POY, and he's the favorite for HS POY this season.

The kids not had a break in 2 years, from playing juinor HS, to AU ball, to HS camps, to coming back to Aus to attempt to get into the Boomers WC team and then straight back to senior season in HS.. and people are knocking him for enrolling in summer school so he can hit the gym and work on his skills without having to fly over the US every week(or the World if he played U19's)

Some times a person needs to put his best interests in front of representing his country. And yeah like I said Im disappointed it looks like we'll be missing most of our best players. I can't fault his decision. Same goes with Isaac Humphries, he'll only ever have the one chance to play AU ball, the skill camps etc and the timer conflicts with rep ball.

Reply #516157 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Simmons is a one-and-done player, what if he wants to be at LSU a bit longer since he only has one year there - make the most out of his time there. He'll have plenty of time to play for Australia, let the kid make the decision that he feels is best for him.


Hate to break it to you but college doesn't start till fall, the camps during the school break so too the worlds, so that point is mute, lol
Why won't people just accept this kid is making excuses , and you have to ask why.....not one answer is favourable

Reply #516158 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Reply #516149

That's true. If it's a dumb opinion it should be criticized and scrutinized, what's your point? This is a forum for that kind of banter isn't it? You're pretty chilled you say yet your opinions indicate otherwise.

I struggle to understand why you think it's necessary for Simmons to play? Is it to appease your own sense of patriotism? Fair enough you're being critical of his choice but to claim he should never play for Australia again even at senior level is ludicrous and plain arrogant.

Hence get off you high horse mate! reeks of tall poppy syndrome.

No one ever said they have a "right" to play for their country but there's also the fact that it's only basketball..

He's already given an excuse, do you really believe there are deep seeded issues in his decision?

Reply #516206 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago



#516206

Whoa there!! Been for a gallop on the big horse. Just catching my breath.

Get yourself some glasses. Fair dinkum. Never said anywhere that Simmons shouldn't ever play for Australia again on the back of this.

Thanks, some of you guys have provided some good laughs while you rant and try to insult me.

Reply #516219 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

Its bloody under 19s! Lets not get tall poppy syndrome and hate on the kid for this. Next year is the Olympics, and I am guessing he will be playing that.

Reply #516225 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

ummm yes you did..

re: Ben Simmons to miss U19 World Champs


"Sorry but if Simmons can't take the time to play for his country at this age then he's really not worthy of a spot when older."

Reply #516265 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago



Ummmmm,

No I did not.

Different anonymous, not me.

Reply #516289 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

haha oops. my bad

Reply #516304 | Report this post


....?  
Years ago

To my knowledge it is a general accepted policy that Students who attend College as student athletes are expected to attend summer Classes so that they can meet their academic requirements given that during the actual season their chosen sport is played in normally means they do not attend many classes.

LSU as a college has faced sanctions is the past for student athletes academic problems and may very well have a policy that dictates all athletics must attend summer school.

Ben seems to be the type of guy who loves to play against the best opposition possible and if he could do both most likely would. Keep in mind his God father who is a coach at LSU is also the same man who pushed Patty Mills and Dante Exum to play at the U19's so do not see why he would not do the same now with Ben unless the above school policy is in play.

Reply #517249 | Report this post




You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.



Close ads
Little Streaks - The fun and interactive good-habits app designed especially for kids.
Serio: Tourism photography and videography

Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.

Recent Posts



.


An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 10:52 am, Thu 25 Apr 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754