Anonymous
Years ago

Thon Maker to play for Canada?

From the West Australian:

Teenage prodigy Thon Maker could be playing for Canada not Australia at future Olympics.

Rowan Barnett executive Vice President of basketball Canada, said his organisation was eyeing Maker and his talented younger brother Matur

Topic #36798 | Report this topic


Darryl  
Years ago

Saw the same article would be a shame but with that said you can't miss what you never had.

Reply #522827 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

This all comes down to loyalty for me. Are you going to play for Australia, the country which took you from poverty and a war torn environment and gave you a livelihood. Or, are you going to play for Canada? A country you have been in for about a minute now? Not playing for Australia would seem pretty unappreciative in my eyes. Basketball Australia needs to jump on this now, and get these guys on a junior national team or into the Oceania qualifiers or they can blame themselves for losing them.

What is the schedule like for the Oceania lead up? Isnt there a camp set in the US?

Reply #522828 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

How many times can this be brought up ffs!

Reply #522829 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Aus bball prospects has said that Thon was committed to playing for Australia.

I don't know what to believe anymore....

Reply #522830 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

Well, to put this in perspective, this isn't based on anything Thon has said. This is based on something the Canadian Basketball head honcho has said. It would certainly have me salty if they do play for Canada, but at this point, Thon and his controlling parasitic growth haven't said anything to the effect of him playing for Canada.

Reply #522831 | Report this post


NBL Fan  
Years ago

Which country isn't he going to play for...

Reply #522834 | Report this post


El Diablo  
Years ago

If he doesn't believe he is in Australian, then f&ck him

Reply #522837 | Report this post


Benno  
Years ago

Load of shit, is playing for AUS at nike hoop summit.

Reply #522842 | Report this post


LC  
Years ago

Olgun Uluc, an editor on the PnR site, met with Ed Smith (Thon's guardian) recently and has been assured the desire is to play for Australia and the Canada option isn't even being considered.

You can read some more prior to his conversation with Smith here:

Thon Maker won't play for the Australian U19 Emus; Other US-based players yet to commit

Reply #522843 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Lol if Ed Smiths word isn't true, then who's is?!?!

Reply #522845 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

We need to wine and dine the maker family. Perhaps put them into camp for boomers this year

Reply #522847 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

First of let me just say that Ed Smith makes the hair on my back stand on end. The whole thing just seems strange to say the least. However, you could look at it on the flipside. What has he done for Thon? Where would Thon be without him? Is this a legitimate business venture?

OR

is he just perpetuating the slave trade? Trading flesh for profit? Gaining ownership over a child and using that child for the sole purpose of making a profit?

The whole thing is not only strange but it is also fascinating....... If Ed and Thon wrote a book on their "relationship" I'd be the first to buy it to see what their motives were and how each party benefited.

Reply #522850 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

7ft athletic kids with skills get noticed when playing junior basketball in Australia.

He would have went to the CoE and could have followed the Isaac Humphries route. That may have put him a year behind where he is now, although people expect bigs to develop more slowly and having that mystic of less exposure in the states can help, like it did with Dante.

Reply #522851 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Good choice... Why play for a country that hates refugees...

Reply #522856 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Do it Thon! Play for a country that actually wants you... Australian basketball is dead take a look at the NBA.. What a joke

Reply #522860 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Boomers never wanted him so why not

Reply #522861 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Wasn't Majok one of Smiths boys too?

Reply #522862 | Report this post


The truth  
Years ago

It is clearly obvious that Thon and his brother will play for Canada. You do not need official statements to figure this out... Oh well. We still have Humphries, and Thon is over-hyped anyway. And with his weight and body structure, he'll get destroyed in the NBA.

Reply #522864 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I think he will bust anyway, he's already what? 22? and still hasn't put on mass.. also shoots ~30% vs high school kids.. no big loss for the Boomers

Reply #522866 | Report this post


maxymoo  
Years ago

Jeebus - it's not a political statement, he'll play where he plays.

If it's Canada - enjoy it.

Reply #522870 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Agree with maxy... Let him play where he wants...

would be great to have a front court of Simmons(sf), t.maker(pf), Humphries(c) in the future. Add backups in the front court like adel, McVeigh, bolden, m.maker and maybe Malone, landale or perry and you've got an unbelievable squad that are all u20. A team that could potentially win a major event in the future...

Reply #522871 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

McVeigh?

Reply #522882 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Here's the latest on it:

http://wwos.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=8971467

Reply #522888 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

^ That's a nothing article. Just regurgitation from the article in the OP. It has nothing to do with Thon's intentions

Reply #522899 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I think everyone should cool it. Firstly, there is a very long way to go before any of these KIDS represent the Boomers in an Olympics!

IMHO, If he wants to play for Canada, then really that is his choice.

How would any of you like Anons telling you what you should be doing?

Reply #522916 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

I've been reading all off these Thon Maker posts over time and it is weird how some people are so attached to the situation. There is almost a master-slave relationship here with the posters who feel that Australia saved him from poverty. How do we even know he was poor leaving Sudan. It is the assumption that all Sudanese who came to this country were poor, running from war, and needed to be saved by Australia. Same stolen generation mentality.
The next thing is the attack on his coach Ed Smith. It is assumed that he has taken advantage of a poor illiterate kid and spent all this time and money to coach him and take him to the U.S. Fom all reports, Thon did not play basketball until he met Smith and was in Australia since he was 6yrs old. So if he started working with Smith at 13, Australia had enough opportunity to see him and provide the same training for 7yrs.

Reply #522945 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Furthermore on this subject, does Ed Smith have the magic formula for working with Sudanese. How come the COE or any of these basketball associations have not produced Sudanese players at this level. It seems that they are having success with other Australians. It is a case of Johnny come lately. From all accounts, Ed Smith is from a basketball family:
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/meet-the-personal-stats-analyst-who-helped-kevin-durant-win-the-mvp/.
If he has resources like this, what family would not pay top dollars for this type of access. Would this be a problem if the kid was Italian and paid Smith top dollars for this and wanted to become a citizen for another country? Let's not forget, Australia was a refuge for migrating Italians also.
I think it is Thon's choice and it is not a choice because he owes Australia but because he loves Australia enough to forgo other opportunities that may be better for him financially. This is almost like telling companies not to relocate overseas because the opportunity in Australia may not be as great or on the flip side telling an Australian who played soccer in Europe since 13 not to return to Australia because the European country has done so much for him. It is the individuals choice.

Reply #522947 | Report this post


Hoop-headPHD  
Years ago

I agree with that analysis of some posters treating Thon Maker as "Property" and feel that many feel he owes them something or is sort of a "slave" relationship.

The maker parents decided that after meeting Ed Smith, it would be better for Thon and Matur's educational and to a lesser extent, also better in their sporting careers going forwards to allow Mr. Smith to take both children to Australia to get a better education there.

Overtime it became more clear that as the children grew they would have a serious shot a pro basketball so the next step was to move the children to North America to continue with the best coaches and training facilities it the "meca" of basketball.

There is no indication that the makers were these desperate, broken children that were saved BT Australia by any aacounts. So this story should be about what's best for Thon and Mature and what do they want? What is the bestcmove for their careers going forwards?

I would think that the Canadian option is currently their best options going forwards to receive the funding, access to top notch training facilities and training that is needed to get to the next level. It would be impossible for them to fly back and forth to Australia on thief own dime at this point which is unfortunate for Australia and is something they are gradually working to fix.

In Canada we don't believe that new Canadians owe us anything and we have a great and growing African population that no doubt the Makers have had a chance to meet once in T.O. Canada is one of the most ethnic diverse nations in the world and in most areas there are no signs racism like many other countries. Canada would go crazy if Thon chose to represent Canada, but trust me one in Canada "expects" anything from him but to be himself and to do what is in his heart.

The interesting dynamic to all of this is that in the world of competitive Tennis, which I used to play as a kid, is exactly this way, all the time.

In Tennis eventually a senior tennis coach or ex tennis player discovers 1 or 2 very good young players that might one day have a chance at going pro, so they do the same thing as Ed Smith does. They usually move away to somewhere they can play all the time, (In tennis that is usually Florida) and basically spend the next 4 to 5 years training these kids for little money hoping that maybe if this kid goes pro it will open doors for him in the future, because all personal elite coaches no that this is a money losing venture in the end. Milos Roanic's coach said that this is exactly what he did for Milos and even though they remain tight until today, he could never personally mentor someone like that again. He estimated that it would have coated roughly $70,000 a year to train one elite child and admits that he only billed the Roanic' less than 20% of the cost should of been.

So in the end, if Ed Smith gets $100,000 so what? Just as long as he is listening to the Maker's wishes and is trying to help them.

There are many sports where it takes random acts of jeneroucity to identify and train young and talented promising stars, so how is what Ed Smith doing any different than any other youth coach..?

It is clear that Ed Smith is simply helping the kids get better, giving his opinion when needed on basketball related stufc and giving the kids more choices than they would normally have.

I think some people are just jelious, because this kid has so much potential and by moving to Canada he now sits as one of the most exciting prospects in a generation with no one pulling his strings or telling him #what to do."

He could go pro for a year in Canada/Europe/Australia/China...??

He could also stay another year and play a post-grad year in Canada than go pro. Or he could do college. I think it's clear that the Maker's are getting great advice and have been making great decisions all along by the number of option currently available for them.

Reply #523062 | Report this post


Hoop-headPHD  
Years ago

I agree with that analysis of some posters treating Thon Maker as "Property" and feel that many feel he owes them something or is sort of a "slave" mastet type relationship.

The maker parents decided that after meeting Ed Smith, it would be better for Thon and Matur's educational and to a lesser extent, also better in their sporting careers going forwards to allow Mr. Smith to take both children to Australia to get a better education there.

Overtime it became more clear that as the children grew they would have a serious shot a pro basketball so the next step was to move the children to North America to continue with the best coaches and training facilities at the "meca" of basketball since it was clear now the kids had grown into real basketball players rather soccer.

There is no indication that the makers were ever these pore desperate, refugee children that were saved by Australia by any aacounts, the family made a lifestyle choice. So this story should really be about what's best for Thon and Mature and not of them "paying. Off" some made-up debyt thay they somehow owe Asyralia??


This should be about what do they want and what is best for their careers going forwards?

I would think that the Canadian option is currently their best options going forwards to receive the funding, access to top notch training facilities and training that is needed to get to the next level. It would be impossible for them to fly back and forth to Australia on thief own dime at this point which is unfortunate for Australia and is something they are gradually working to fix. Also the Canadian Team could be a serious gold medal threat in 4 to 5 years with a team based around him and Andrew Wiggens with a Roster of all NBA lottery picks. Unfortunately North America is just to far away to really care about what's going on in Australia so sponser and endorsement dollars would be much greater here.

In Canada we don't believe that new Canadians owe us anything and we also have a huge, vibrant and growing African population that no doubt the Makers have had a chance to meet once in T.O. Canada is one of the most ethnic diverse nations in the world and in most areas there are no signs racism like many other countries. Canada would go crazy if Thon chose to represent Canada, but trust me one in Canada "expects" anything from him but to be himself and to do what is in his heart.

The interesting dynamic to all of this is that in the world of competitive Tennis, which I used to play as a kid, is exactly this way, all the time.

In Tennis eventually a senior tennis coach or ex tennis player discovers 1 or 2 very good young players that might one day have a chance at going pro, so they do the same thing as Ed Smith does. They usually move away to somewhere they can play all the time, (In tennis that is usually Florida) and basically spend the next 4 to 5 years training these kids for little money hoping that maybe if this kid goes pro it will open doors for him in the future, because all personal elite coaches no that this is a money losing venture in the end. Milos Roanic's coach said that this is exactly what he did for Milos and even though they remain tight until today, he could never personally mentor someone like that again. He estimated that it would have coated roughly $70,000 a year to train one elite child and admits that he only billed the Roanic' less than 20% of the cost should of been.

So in the end, if Ed Smith gets $100,000 so what? Just as long as he is listening to the Maker's wishes and is trying to help them.

There are many sports where it takes random acts of jeneroucity to identify and train young and talented promising stars, so how is what Ed Smith doing any different than any other youth coach..?

It is clear that Ed Smith is simply helping the kids get better, giving his opinion when needed on basketball related stufc and giving the kids more choices than they would normally have.

I think some people are just jelious, because this kid has so much potential and by moving to Canada he now sits as one of the most exciting prospects in a generation with no one pulling his strings or telling him #what to do."

He could go pro for a year in Canada/Europe/Australia/China...??

He could also stay another year and play a post-grad year in Canada than go pro. Or he could do college. I think it's clear that the Maker's are getting great advice and have been making great decisions all along by the number of option currently available for them.

Reply #523068 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Hoop headPHD:
Your argument is valid but spell check if you're going to use "PHD" as an acronym. The spelling mistakes take away from a compelling argument and allows posters to diverge from the issues at hand.

Reply #523082 | Report this post


Hoop-headPHD  
Years ago

It's the people with little education that take issues with spell checking. People like myself you are university graduates and working in highly competive careers are often to busy in the real world to wory about his smart phone improperly using it's auto correct function and it leading to a few crammer/spelling mistakes.

I could care less if a few internet troles notice a few spelling or grammer mistakes on 3 page essay typed out on a one us one smart phone?? I actually prefer to weed those people out because I am speaking to the mored educated and informed audience.

As you go through post secondary and than head into your professional life and have thus written thousand and thousands of stuttered, grammatically correct, esays/reports eventually you to start to appreciate the freedom of writing an "un-edited"/un-filtered unbiased personal opinion on something the actually care about.

Yes I could have used an actual computer or even spell-checker but the entire point of that post was to finally give people online something to think about when constantly ripping apart a poor teenager that happens to be good at basketball.

He is a human being that did come from a tough part of the world and so far his only crime is being good at basketball but "open to playing basketball where it will most help him become to one day become professional basketball player"???

So the people who read my earlier post and immediately thought of the 3 to 4 auto correct spelling errors after reading it are not the people that I am reaching for here. It is the people who care about other human beings and respect everyone as being equal and free to choose their own destiny.

To me me that concept is much more important than "auto correct"!

Reply #523113 | Report this post


Hoop-headPHD  
Years ago

Secondly, it's not an argument it is clear example of some people acting horribly to a couple of poor yong teenagers who have done no wrong.

An argument would involve 2 actual sides to an invigerating equation but my point was just bring to light some examples of horrible injustice to 2 young kids.

I could have argued that Thon was only in Australia a few years and has spent the bulk of the past 14 months in Canada and predominantly the US and Canada before that. The cost for him and his brother to attend the spe ial school in Canada as a foreign apicant would be roughly $40,000 a year for him and his brother yet we are providing everything for free?

So does he owe Canada than..?

No he does not owe anybody anything, he and his even you ger brother have themselves and their families who live in a dangerous part of the world to think about.

Whether either of them even tries out for our any of our national team's is irrelevant, we thank them for spending time in our country and appreciate them for any help along the way.

Canada has an extensive history in welcoming visitors or immigrants especially people from Africa as well as Australia. Thon actually mentions that he likes Canada so much because it reminds him of Australia so it's clear they still like Australia and are only going to consider possibly one other country,(Canada) if they do end up having to represent another nation.

Canada used to lose dozens of top athletes ea h year to the US and Canada so we know how frustrating it can be to lose an exiting prospect.

The good news is that Basketball Australia is starting to realize that they need to adjust their system fast or they could possibly loose out on more kids so they are adapting thief "requirements"

Soon the NBA all-star games will be like Nike Hoop Summit's and rookie softmore games and it will be all countries vs the US, so hey if he does plat for Canada he will likely be playing for an "amalgamated" "world" team soon anyways.

There was even a roomer after the lopsided U19 men's and women's plus and past world cup and olympics that Fiba may try a 4 continents theme because the US was hammering everyone.

As a basketball parity fan I am hoping for a team to rival and truly test the US in basketball. With the makers plus our stacked young team I would think Canada is really the only country to be able to do that.

Australia is not far behind and could easilly challenge for a top 4 finish in the world, but they could never truly challenge the US for Gold.

Reply #523118 | Report this post


GWB  
Years ago

I don't think challenging for gold is really Australia's intention. We want to stand up and be counted. Be recognised. This wont happen in some 4 nations = 1 team scenario. We are here for medals, and here to punch above our weight.

As for the Thon Maker deal, it is indeed up to them who they represent... if anyone. But I couldn't help being a bit salty if they represent Canada. Basketball Australia need to work on making camps easier to get to for the Makers.

Reply #523123 | Report this post


smoke  
Years ago

I caught up with a Melbourne based organiser of sudanese basketball this week and he told me that he expects Thon to put on the green and gold. More at:
http://melbourneunibasketball.org.au/news/2015/longhorns-basketball-club

Reply #523343 | Report this post


Andrew Wiggins  
Years ago

Thon should definitely play for Canada. Did you guys see my 3 posters last game? Who wouldn't want to play for the next Jordan of this league? Australia's got an alright squad but Canada is going to be rejecting guys that would start on Australia by the time 2020 comes. Hell Thon might not even make team Canada and his bro probably won't.

Reply #523429 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Thon can play for Canada. Canada aren't medalling anytime soon. Aus will be in future look at our squad. Bad mistake Thon sucked in.

Reply #523476 | Report this post


Anonymous  
Years ago

Canada aren't medallion anytime soon?!
2020 will be a chance then can lock in top 3 every major tournament after that. Look at what's happening there.

Reply #523484 | Report this post




You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.



Close ads
Little Streaks - The fun and interactive good-habits app designed especially for kids.
Serio: Tourism photography and videography

Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.

Recent Posts



.


An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 2:51 pm, Thu 25 Apr 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754