Swish n' Dish
Years ago
Noticed in a weekly CPA email I received, there was a ruling on a tax appeal for a financial supporter of the Hawks. Thought you may be interested in case you ever decide to 'invest' in an NBL club!
http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/AATA/2012/862.html
Anonymous
Years ago
18:10 13 Dec 12
Tax man is about to wind up a Newcastle NRL side as well.
Anonymous
Years ago
20:58 13 Dec 12
http://www.news.com.au/top-stories/future-of-newcastle-knights-newcastle-jets-under-cloud-after-ato-moves-on-owner-nathan-tinkler/story-e6frfkp9-1226536049533
Anonymous
Years ago
22:29 13 Dec 12
Good move that the Hawks are now community owned and not privately owned like it was in regards to this ruling.
Obviously private ownership has its issues reading this story.
billo
Years ago
22:50 13 Dec 12
That was interesting, I would have thought that losses made running a sports club would have been deductible but in this instance they apparently were not.
Looks like the ATO viewed the money he poured into the club as more like an expensive hobby, a venture that wasn't entered into for the purpose of producing assessable income - seems like a pretty harsh ruling but I don't know the full story.
Paging Rat10, we need your input.
Rat10
Years ago
10:43 14 Dec 12
CA's represent Billo!
Interesting case. The Commiss spells it out pretty clearly in paragraphs 19-29 why the losses weren't deductible.
He clearly didn't treat the "investment" with the level of commerciality necessary for it to be considered as a business and claim the losses as a deduction.
I would have thought the losses are more capital in nature so he could offset them against future capital gains.
Never thought I'd be talking about this on a Hoops forum!
Jack Toft
Years ago
11:53 14 Dec 12
Rat10, I would have thought those losses were more capital in nature as well.
He injected his money into the Hawks in the form of a share purchase, so one would expect that the capital loss as a result of share sales be brought forward (it can be advanced for up to 3 years I believe) The only other way would have been to inject it as a loan with a nominal interest rate.
It could be assumed that the share value of an NBL team would be pretty static. Seems to me the smart way would be to have 100 $2 shares and if he wanted to invest in the team, buy a set amount of shares from other directors and get on the board.
Sporting teams never give a massive return and the likelihood of a loss is great, so prepare to lose some money. I think that the best way to invest in a NBL club is to inject the money in as sponsorship. Any sponsorship investment is tax deductible as an operating expense and any return from that investment (ie excess to operating expenses) would be achieved either as a Directors fee, or as a dividend from shares.
Anonymous
Years ago
11:58 14 Dec 12
Jack, I think you're spot on. Can't see there being an argument about this crystallising a capital loss - and contributing via sponsorship (assuming the acknowledgement of the sponsorship is public enough) would remove any grey area.
Jack Toft
Years ago
12:23 14 Dec 12
that's right anon, if sponsorship is done right with the proper acknowledgement etc, then it is a legit expense.
If they purchase a nominal set of shares (eg 10 off @ $2 each), then they jump on board as a director and any "excess" left over at the end of the year, can be paid to them as a director's fee, or else divided up amongst all shareholders. Then, when they want to leave, the company, or others can buy the shares back at a set nominal rate of $2. Everyone is happy and there's no capital gains issues.
It's dangerous to invest in something like this by buying shares, particularly if the money is being used for day to day expenses, which I assume the $350K was used for. It's a different story if the Hawks went capital raising for a new stadium or the like.
Clapped Out Hack
Years ago
13:05 14 Dec 12
Just a question. If he managed to make a profit from the investment would the Tax man then come knocking? Or would this ruling make the profits Tax free?
Isaac
Years ago
13:34 14 Dec 12
Hack, good question. Keen to hear some guesses from those working in this field.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 4:16 pm, Fri 27 Apr 2018 | Posts: 711,992 | Last 7 days: 1,605
