An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 6:26 am, Mon 21 Apr 2014 | Posts: 490,887 | Last 7 days: 1,149

Dunk Basketball Uniforms   West Adelaide Bearcats Mid-Year Carnival - July 10-13, 2014

2FAST4U
Last year

#30836

Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Which player is/was better?

I was thinking of this comparison before and realized they both play fairly similiarly in that they both play like undersized SG in the PG position.

Athleticism- Shane Heal could never really dunk or anything but Mills isn't a flyer either. Speed wise would defs go to Mill.

Longetivity- Heal.

Skill wise they match up fairly even for me except Mills has done more on the international scale especially in the olympics. Heal played NBA as well but he never was really given the chance to prove himself but NBL wise the edge goes to Heal.

Thoughts?


Report this topic


 

Isaac
Last year
20:40 15 Feb 13

Reply #404722

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

NBL-wise, Heal had a little bit more than an edge...

Interesting comparison though.


Report this post



The voice of Reason
Last year
20:43 15 Feb 13

Reply #404723

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

let mills finish his career before we compare


Report this post



paul
Last year
20:55 15 Feb 13

Reply #404726

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Heal clearly at this stage, but Patty's got plenty of years to catch up.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
00:26 16 Feb 13

Reply #404748

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Mills is already the better player but Heal has the achievements due to the length of his career.


Report this post



SMA
Last year
01:18 16 Feb 13

Reply #404751

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Tough call. But Heal has the edge for me!

He got some short stints in the NBA and deserved better.

At NBL level he was $$$$.

Mills is a chance to catch him. But while NBA is great from him we may miss him matching Hammers NBL exploits...which is a shame.


Report this post



Oz
Last year
01:49 16 Feb 13

Reply #404762

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Heal was better.


Report this post



jay ray
Last year
06:46 16 Feb 13

Reply #404777

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Mills wouldn't give the Adelaide crowd a "One Finger Salute" while leaving the floor after a game!


Report this post



Moses Malone
Last year
11:50 16 Feb 13

Reply #404823

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Good topic.

Would rate Heal a superior shooter, scorer, passer and even floor general.....Patty, a better athlete.

No gears in Patty's game...lacks tempo, distribution and good shot/bad shot recognition.

Don't really rate either defensively, although Patty has the physical ability to get into the ball handler but lacks physicality in the half court (and flops way too much). Hammer....never afraid to give you a smack off the ball to know you're in a dogfight, but not really gonna get after someone 90ft.

Heal the better player.


Report this post



SamCro
Last year
14:25 16 Feb 13

Reply #404845

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

No contest here, if both were in the prime playing against each other Mills would embarass Heal IMO. Mills blistering speed & crossover would snap Heal's ankle in two. Heal a superior shooter than Mills for sure from deep but overall I think Mills has the better skill set between the two. You wouldnt call either of them defensive hounds but I give Mills the slight edge in this department. Both fiercely competitive & have both represented Australia with great distinction over the years!


Report this post



Uncle fester
Last year
15:02 16 Feb 13

Reply #404856

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Mills can score at will, heal can not. Mills also ruthless on defence.

Also, patty is a wayyyyy better person. Nice guy whilst heal is arrogant.


Report this post



sitiveni
Last year
16:42 16 Feb 13

Reply #404869

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Heal and Gaze our best backcourt.


Report this post



Beekayz
Last year
18:37 16 Feb 13

Reply #404893

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

"Mills wouldn't give the Adelaide crowd a "One Finger Salute" while leaving the floor after a game!"

@jay ray No, he would have given a "One Towel Salute"

Slightly off topic, but are there any Australian players that you guys think have/had the talent to play in the NBA?

Or did play in the NBA but if they'd arrived earlier in their career/ got more of a chance would have done more than take the 12th spot on the roster?


Report this post



dribbler
Last year
19:09 16 Feb 13

Reply #404903

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Thought Simon Dwight could have been decent role player in NBA if developed properly and stayed injury free. Was a world class shot blocker in his prime.


Report this post



Proud
Last year
01:05 17 Feb 13

Reply #405011

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

I don't wanna sound critical of Mills but Heal had more pride in the way he performed out on court and was so much more clutch (absolute $)

It would have been interesting to hear of Heal's legacy without Gaze overshadowing him. Heal more than held his own when we had amazing import point guards.

I haven't seen Mills in NBA besides for Portland so probably not giving him enough credit.

But I'd trust Heal more than Mills to get the win


Report this post



sitiveni
Last year
15:35 17 Feb 13

Reply #405092

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Dribbler i hear you. Simon Dwight and Sammy Mac were my 2 favourite players. Its a shame injuries hurt both players.


Report this post



Bear
Last year
10:56 18 Feb 13

Reply #405260

re: Shane Heal V Patty Mills

Too early to call, way too early! Re visit this post in 8 years time, perhaps?


Report this post





 

Reply to this topic

Name Email

Random name suggestion for anonymous posters: Mimas 63

Title
Rules: You must read the Terms of Use. No spam, no offensive material, no sniping at other clubs, no 'who cares?'-type comments, no naming or bashing under 18 players.
Message

Please proof-read your post before submitting as you will not be able to edit it afterwards.
 


Recent Posts

.
.