Dunk Basketball Uniforms Aussie Basketball Travellers
NBL.TV - get it now!

AD: Office space available in Adelaide CBD @ 313 Halifax St;
Suit creatives; freelance desks or space for 2-4 person business. More info

Pelican
Last year

#40387

Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Might sound like a stupid question to some but considering he is the best import we have had in years do we fork out the cash to keep him another year or even another two?

He is on a rumored 300,000 - which could go into getting two very good imports rather than one superstar.

I would like to see Ekene Ibekwe in a 36ers uniform next year and for them to lock up Sobey for another 2 years.

Report this topic


 

KET
Last year
18:32 3 Dec 16

Reply #611066

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Good question, i'd say if possible absolutely - an import with a track record of 20ppg and around the MVP standard you can't go past that.

Obviously it's dependent on finances.

The 36ers badly need to raise more capital if they want to be able to compete in the NBL, even if it's to avoid other teams poaching the likes of Sobey, Hodgson, Drmic, Deng etc.


Report this post



Pelican
Last year
18:44 3 Dec 16

Reply #611070

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Deng's on a 3 year deal and is an Adelaide boy who wants to stay with his family so I doubt he is going anywhere unless it is in the NBA for the opportunity.

Drmic, Hodgson, Sobey could be poached but I guess it comes to loyalty to teams and you see more of that in the NBL than any other sporting code in Australia.


Report this post



Dazz
Last year
19:14 3 Dec 16

Reply #611082

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

If Randle is costing you only $300k, then absolutely lock him in. Maybe they need to look at what they are paying others, or they need to go begging to some sponsors and get some more cash to surround him with a bit better quality.
Get some mature, cheap, role players, eg somebody that can play solid D and grab a few boards.

Maybe chase one more decent scorer?


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
19:14 3 Dec 16

Reply #611083

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

$300,00 in a losing side is ludicrous.


Report this post



lawsy
Last year
19:22 3 Dec 16

Reply #611089

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

$300k!! Lock him up.. he's worth $600k in top European league, so I doubt you'll se hik here


Report this post



Hendo8888
Last year
19:56 3 Dec 16

Reply #611102

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Is the Pope Catholic?


Report this post



Wilson Sting
Last year
19:58 3 Dec 16

Reply #611105

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Nah, just rely on Creek or Teys to be your go to man.


Report this post



Pelican
Last year
20:01 3 Dec 16

Reply #611108

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Losing side? Wow from where I am standing they don't look like a losing side - they are on par with any team bar Sydney in the league.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
21:24 3 Dec 16

Reply #611211

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Down the stretch in overtime Randle went jungle. Nearly cost them the game.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
21:30 3 Dec 16

Reply #611216

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

They should keep Randle as long as he is not ridiculously priced.

The Sixers are one top player from being a really good team.

As Joey said in the paper corporate support is the key to move from a good team to a great team.


Report this post



Brunson
Last year
22:12 3 Dec 16

Reply #611226

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

My guess is Randle's sponsor pays a large amount of it. As long as they are happy to do that then we will keep him, otherwise it will be hard to find the money.


Report this post



Dazz
Last year
22:32 3 Dec 16

Reply #611234

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Adelaide MUST spend at least the salary floor, and that will probably increase considering the cap is supposed to move based on average spend.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
22:52 3 Dec 16

Reply #611245

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

For the right price yes. BUT he is only any good for the 36ers if they can compliment him with better pieces. Otherwise no point paying top dollar for a Ferrai, if you cant afford the petrol and it becomes a wasted purchase.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
23:40 3 Dec 16

Reply #611250

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

No team with randel as their top guy will win a ring. To selfish


Report this post



Luuuc
Last year
23:51 3 Dec 16

Reply #611253

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

How you gonna call him selfish? He was penetrating our D and hitting open guys all night. 6 assists plus a good number of hockey assists.


Report this post



ME
Last year
00:31 4 Dec 16

Reply #611259

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

I wouldn't call Randle selfish. I would just say he gets next to no help from anyone around him. Other than Johnson, who else can get buckets on a regular basis? Adelaide has come to a point where a non-scorer like Sobey is putting up numbers out of necessity. I think they should lock Randle in for the future if they can afford to do so while surrounding him with worthy talent. I should hope we're not having to rely on the same standard of supporting imports next season.


Report this post



HoldenV8
Last year
01:07 4 Dec 16

Reply #611268

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Calling Randle selfish is like saying Robert Rose was.

A lot of people thought that Rose was selfish, though most overlooked it because he was so good. But he really wasn't and it wasn't unusual to see his stat line read that along with his usual 25+ points and whatever rebounds, he would give out somewhere near 10 assists.

As Brett Maher said about him, the problem was that because he could just about do it all, those around him tended to sit back a bit and let him do everything.

Randle isn't selfish, but like Rose when you are that much better than those around you then you are going to end up with the ball a lot more. And given that he's the point guard, of course he is going to have it more than most.

Personally I would rather Adelaide keep him, especially if they are getting away with it for only around $300k a season. He's a proven NBL performer. Besides that, its nice to have a regular import rather than the one year wonders we've had here in the past 6-7 years.


Report this post



paul
Last year
06:11 4 Dec 16

Reply #611275

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

A player can be a selfish ball hog and still have a lots of assists. Sometimes they won't give the ball off unless they think it will lead to an assist next to their name.

In his second year at the Magic I thought Rose was selfish, to the detriment of the team. As for Randle, he is just doing exactly what Joey Wright asks him to and he's doing it exceptionally well.


Report this post



paul
Last year
06:14 4 Dec 16

Reply #611276

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

"Losing side? Wow from where I am standing they don't look like a losing side - they are on par with any team bar Sydney in the league."

The 36ers are 6-6 and one game behind top, so hardly a losing side. And they beat Sydney in Sydney six days ago.


Report this post



KET
Last year
08:37 4 Dec 16

Reply #611284

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Randle going all freaky, penetrating and hop stepping into a jumpshot or a ridiculous floater or an impossible layup over shot blockers are okay because somehow he gets them in - and at a good rate.

Doing the same thing and passing to the open man, Randle does some serious damage to the opposition.

The aspect which looks selfish is when he's too busy holding the ball up, dribbling in the same spot or moving around the same little area (and on occasion losing the ball trying to mess with people without actually trying to make a move to the basket). This is when the 36ers offence is seriously stifled.

The 36ers look good when they push and move the ball. Look at the first half v Perth. They also look bad and incompetent and as if they can't be bothered doing anything when they don't push and move the ball - look at the second half v Perth.

At this point it is important to note as Paul said, Randle could simply be doing what he's told by the coach.

Admittedly during these periods of offence, it does look like the 36ers are attempting offensive sets - they just look like they're walking through it for the first time at training. Effectively, Randle is forced to dribble it around directing people where to go and not really doing much but taking up the clock.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
09:20 4 Dec 16

Reply #611285

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

He had 3 shots I recall in O/t, one never going in, 2nd one blocked and the 3rd the same as the first. In all cases other people were open. That's selfish.


Report this post



ChairmanOfTheBored
Last year
12:04 4 Dec 16

Reply #611293

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Going solo late in the game can be a bit frustrating, but I'd hardly call him selfish. At the start of this season he said he wanted to distribute more and score less. When the season got underway it was clear that the kids he's got around him weren't quite there yet and he had to carry a load. Look at the last 3 games though. He's not scoring 34 a game and carrying the team, he's scoring 20 and we've got a long list of other players chipping in with 9s and 10s. If DJ can maintain his aggressive offence and get Creek back with the same form he showed early then we've got another couple of people who can drop 20 and it starts to look a lot less shaky.
If Randle wants to come back, I say make it happen!


Report this post



snooch
Last year
20:44 4 Dec 16

Reply #611363

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Isn't Randle coming off being named finals MVP in a championship with his team in Europe? Kinda goes against the "won't win a championship" theme..


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
08:11 5 Dec 16

Reply #611374

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

The game was won by Sobey hitting that big 3. If that hadn't happened Randle would have been called selfish.The 3 shots he too were terrible too. The block that occurred was in amongst the tall timber and should never have even been considered, let alone taken.


Report this post



paul
Last year
08:20 5 Dec 16

Reply #611378

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Snooch, yes he is, but he was playing for the team that wins the championship almost every year in Lithuania.


Report this post



XY
Last year
08:50 5 Dec 16

Reply #611379

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

So, Paul, your saying he was the best player on the best team AND he didn't make them worse enough so that they stopped being the best team?

Not sure your qualifying the position in the way you have helps.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
09:12 5 Dec 16

Reply #611383

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Adelaide spend more than the salary cap, they are crying poor but making some really bad financial decisions off court and then crying they need money to compete. Cairns doesn't and look what they put together !!

Randle is quality and worth building something around but talk of $6ooK in Australia is stupid. Stop thinning we can compete with some other rich clubs, Most spending over the cap some just more than others.


Report this post



paul
Last year
09:25 5 Dec 16

Reply #611384

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

What position am I qualifying XY?


Report this post



Camel 31
Last year
09:42 5 Dec 16

Reply #611385

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Craig sitting on the bench at Cairns


Report this post



KET
Last year
09:46 5 Dec 16

Reply #611387

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Anon #611383 are you basing this on what you think or what you know?

I guess we'll find out at the end of the year if they ever end up releasing some sort of list of figures...


Report this post



XY
Last year
10:36 5 Dec 16

Reply #611392

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Paul - 'yes he is, but...'

The usual convention is that the words after 'but' qualify the statement before. Are you saying that Randle's achievement, winning MVP on the championship side, is less impressive because he was on a perennial contender?

First, he must have been good enough to be selected for the best team, secondly, he still had to be the best team's most valuable player and thirdly, he still had to get that team to win the championship?

The anon poster said 'No team with randel as their top guy will win a ring. To selfish'. A team just did, as Snooch pointed out. He clearly wasn't so terrible an MVP that his Lithuanian team couldn't win it because of his selfish play.


Report this post



paul
Last year
10:49 5 Dec 16

Reply #611393

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

What I'm saying is that winning an LKL title with Zalgiris (who could have had any of hundreds of import PGs and still won) doesn't really add anything to the debate about whether he can lead an NBL team to the title.


Report this post



XY
Last year
11:19 5 Dec 16

Reply #611399

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

I agree that it doesn't really add anything to the debate as to whether he could single-handedly take a crap NBL team to the title. But that goes for pretty much anyone. Could Randle have taken last year's Perth team to the title if he were to take Beal's position? I would have thought so (plus I think he would compliment D Martin very well).


Report this post



paul
Last year
11:30 5 Dec 16

Reply #611400

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

I guess a good question is how many teams have won NBL titles with a ball-dominant PG as their main scoring weapon?

There's not many I can think of, but at the same time that doesn't mean it can't happen. One thing's for sure, if Randle leads this Adelaide team to a title he will have done extraordinarily well.


Report this post



LV
Last year
15:42 5 Dec 16

Reply #611473

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

With a cap of $1.1m and assuming you're only willing to spend the cap, if Randle's asking $300K would you keep him?

Yep, I would.


Report this post



LV
Last year
15:44 5 Dec 16

Reply #611474

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Although, I assume if Randle is on 300K then Adelaide might be just a little over the cap?

With 11 players, that would leave 800k for the other 10. You must spend minimum 400k on your lowest 5.


Report this post



Dazz
Last year
15:56 5 Dec 16

Reply #611479

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Teams must spend the Salary floor, which is 90% of the Cap, so currently just shy of $1M.
I suppose one could argue that 30% on one player is excessive, but the floor could increase in future as the cap will be based on average spend. We also don't know much Adelaide is actually spending.


Report this post



KET
Last year
15:57 5 Dec 16

Reply #611480

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

It would be interesting to make predictions on who spends the most from 1 to 8.


Report this post



koberulz
Last year
16:06 5 Dec 16

Reply #611483

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

You must spend minimum 400k on your lowest 5.
It's a maximum, not a minimum.


Report this post



snooch
Last year
16:15 5 Dec 16

Reply #611486

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Can't see Randle leading this Adelaide team to a title, but to say no team with him as their top guy can win one because he's too selfish is not living in reality.

He won a title being the top guy in a top team. The fact that team could have won a title without him is irrelevant, because he was still the top guy on that team.


Report this post



LV
Last year
16:17 5 Dec 16

Reply #611489

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Ah right cheers KR


Report this post



Isaac
Last year
16:17 5 Dec 16

Reply #611490

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Keep in mind also that last season Randle helped bring decent crowds for the 36ers. That's worth something for a club and sport where bums on seats counts.

Townsville's death spiral seemed to coincide with their cutting of Homicide. I'd be wary of a similar effect at a similarly underfunded club.


Report this post



Fundingsland
Last year
16:54 5 Dec 16

Reply #611497

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

36ers and NBL media were promoting a near sell out for last game yet Boti posted crowd numbers of 4700 v Perth.


Report this post



Dazz
Last year
17:22 5 Dec 16

Reply #611501

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

I don't see Randle as "selfish."
I see him as an exceptionally good scoring guard, in a team without too many other options. That's the problem when you're the "go to guy" you have to back yourself.


Report this post



KET
Last year
17:23 5 Dec 16

Reply #611503

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Did look like a fair amount of spare seats on TV.

Ofcourse the other issue is whether Randle even wants to stay. Let's be honest when Melbourne or Sydney or Perth or whomever else with money come calling offering significantly higher $$$, 2 years in a city doesn't create loyalty or goodwill that outweighs the extra money.


Report this post



Anonymous
Last year
18:05 5 Dec 16

Reply #611511

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

If they make the playoffs they should bring him back. With another year under their belt the youngsters could be dangerous


Report this post



paul
Last year
18:19 5 Dec 16

Reply #611515

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

"He won a title being the top guy in a top team."

Snooch, the two situations aren't all that comparable. Was he the top guy at Zalgiris? From the games I saw I'd say not in the same way he is in Adelaide, he was one of a number of key players.

The Finals MVP tag should be taken in the knowledge they won their games by 11, 24, 24 and 27. It's not like he was the man making things happen on key possessions down the stretch, so again that has little crossover to the NBL playoffs.

If you're having a serious discussion about his ability to lead an NBL team to the title, I wouldn't be factoring in his short time at Zalgiris.


Report this post



Zodiac
Last year
18:54 5 Dec 16

Reply #611523

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

Is Brock Motum still coming off the bench for Zalgiris? He was Top 5 in scoring & rebounding in the NBL.

Randle getting the Finals MVP award on the championship team is proof teams can win with Randle starring.


Report this post



paul
Last year
20:04 5 Dec 16

Reply #611537

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

The starting frontcourt on the team they played against in the GF was Angus Brandt and Jerai Grant, so important not to confuse the roster depth of a powerhouse like Zalgiris (for whom Motum is the leading scorer in Euroleague play) with the quality of the LKL.


Report this post



Spinner
Last year
20:36 6 Dec 16

Reply #611706

re: Do 36ers attempt to retain Randle next year?

I thought he had signed for two years or was that just wishful thinking?


Report this post





 

Reply to this topic

Name Email

Random name suggestion for anonymous posters: Green 51

Title
Rules: You must read the Terms of Use. No spam, no offensive material, no sniping at other clubs, no 'who cares?'-type comments, no naming or bashing under 18 players. Learn how to embed YouTube videos or tweets
Message

Please proof-read your post before submitting as you will not be able to edit it afterwards.
 


NBL.TV - Your team, live and free!
Liam Flynn - basketball coaching and consulting

Recent Posts

.

NBL.TV - Your team, anytime, anywhere. Live and free*.
.


An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 5:48 pm, Fri 24 Feb 2017 | Posts: 652,731 | Last 7 days: 2,531