Decided to have a look at the 2023-4 roster vs the 2024-5 roster.
2023-4
Imports: Trentyn Flowers, Trey Kell, Jacob Wylie
Main Roster
Jason Cadee, Isaac Humphries, Mitch McCarron, Kyrin Galloway, Tohi Smith-Milner, Alex Starling, Dejan Vasiljevic, Sunday Dech
Development Players
Fraser Roxburgh, Nick Marshall, Keanu Rasmussen, Jacob Rigoni, Akech Alir, Harvey White
2024-5
Imports: Kendric Davis, Montrezl Harrell, Jarell Martin
Main Roster
Jason Cadee, Isaac Humphries, Dejan Vasiljevic, Sunday Dech, Nick Marshall, Lat Mayen, Ben Griscti, Jacob Rigoni. Alex Starling (4 matches)
Development etc Players
Patrick Darcy, Fiston Ipassou, Keanu Rasmussen, Tom Kubank
The differences: Three new imports
Davis has been consistently good both offensively and defensively.
Harrell good offensively but not so good defensively
Martin, late start, still not fit and does not really fit into the team structure with Harrell. Most probably better off with last seasons Galloway. Mayen has had some moments but not getting enough opportunities to get consistency and consistency is perhaps why lack of opportunities.
Change Martin for a mobile 3/4 and team balance would be a lot better, but lack of 5 backup.
Core group of returning Aussies is Cadee, Humphries, Dech and Vasiljevic who get most of the minutes.
Development Players: Marshall and Rigoni upgraded to main roster - locals but no Brett Marr amongst them.
Games played and this is where it gets interesting and perhaps one reason why the team is disjointed
16 Games: Nick Marshall, Jason Cadee
15 Games: Isaac Humphries, Lay Mayen
14 Games: Kendric Davis, Sunday Dech
13 Games: Montrezl Harrell
12 Games: Dejan Vasiljevic
10 Games: Jarell Martin
8 Games: Jacob Rigoni
7 Games: Keanu Rasmussen
Defence is still the 36ers main problem and has been for several years under every coach during this time. There are a few good defenders in the team but overall team defence is just not up to par.
As commented by others, just about every team is impacted when a couple of main roster players are out injured. However for the 36ers it seems that playing away from Adelaide also has an impact. Need to win on the road and start doing it soon or yet another season gone.
The Ninnis Effect
As previously mentioned - get over it. He isnt the coach and theorising what may or may not have happened is just that. Yes coaches do make a difference. Ken Cole and Gary Fox with basically the same roster is an example of the extra 5% that gets a team over the line. However would Nissis have had the same effect with the 2024-5 version with the changes to the roster and managing the egos?