Bulldog
Years ago
Just thought a few people might be interested in an article on FoxSports.com.au about the points system and how it has not worked to even up the league.
Singles out Melbourne and Brisbane, but strangely omits Sydney and their points reduction for Russell Hinder.
http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,20718280-23769,00.html
Isaac
Years ago
This is damning IMO:
Cairns Taipans were also after Dench and were trying to sign him at nine points, however, it appears he was intent on playing for Melbourne and stalled negotiations.
Sector 7G
Years ago
Is there anywhere where clubs points are listed?
Sounds like an unworkable subjective system. Looks like its as effective as the salary cap.
Kent Brockman
Years ago
was listed on the NBL website at one stage.
XY
Years ago
What is strange about it Isaac? Morrissey is the most pro-Sydney reporter going around, just tipping out our Boti for most biased one-eyed reporting of basketball.
The Journo
Years ago
Would a team like this be under the points system??
Horvarth
Rychart
Wheeler
Maher
Newley
Ingles
Forman
Holmes
Nash
Hill
Just curious? Isaac I bet you could tell me yay or nay on this one?
If its a yay, then send it directly to Mal!
Isaac
Years ago
Not anymore. Newley, Ingles, Forman and Holmes would all come back uncapped - had they been signed here from the start, all would be 5s. Newley would be a 9 or 10. Ingles probably an 8-9, Forman 8, Holmes 9, although some could be revised down based on this season's stats - hard to know what calculations they'll use for next year. I'd guess Forman to be a 7 (playing more minutes for the same stats) and Holmes an 8 (has dropped a bit in scoring while still playing good minutes).
The Journo
Years ago
Thanks Isaac and there you go 36ers fans, what MIGHT and SHOULD have been.........
yogee
Years ago
Isaac - Holmes & Forman would still get a reduction as if they came back, as Adelaide is where they started their careers...Newley and Jingles wouldn't though.
There was some talk a while ago about aligning junior clubs and that way if a player progressed through junior ranks and then played with that club's NBL team, they would still get a points reduction as well, but never eventuated.
Isaac
Years ago
Yogee, I don't believe that's correct. The reduction only exists while you stay with that club. Once you leave, you lose it.
Kent Brockman
Years ago
Yep incorrect Yogee
You only get to take your loyalty points with you if you have logged 10 years+ with one team
Copeland and Bradtke are the only "non loyal" points players to play for teams other than the ones that they acrued their loyalty points for.
This is why Rucker was a 10 point player as he has been to too many teams to get a loyalty discount.
If Brett was to leave the sixers he would be a 5 point player for other teams just as he is for us.
The Journo
Years ago
So IF Adelaide had signed them...
Forman - 5 (now 7-8)
Holmes - 5 (now 8-9)
Newley - 5 (now 8-9)
Ingles - 5 (now 7-8)
Rychart - 10 (Going for citzenship)
Horvath - 10
Maher - 5?
Nash - 5?
Wheeler - ???
Hill - ???
What would Schensher be rated?
Isaac
Years ago
Brockman, I think Brett would be a 7, not a 5. Can't take that start-up discount to another club, just the loyalty discounts (-1 and -3) I think.
DrB
Years ago
Yeah they should look into the salary cap too! Brisbane and Melbourne are cheats!
Sturty6ers
Years ago
I don't know why so many people are listing the Adelaide team that has Ingles Newley Forman Holmes etc in it.
Wake up it is not going to happen.
Farley boys Rep
Years ago
Personally i would have liked to see Darren Ng in that lineup rather than the useless, irritating and turnover bound brad hill.
You need to be a registered user to post from this location. Register here.
Advertise on Hoops to a very focused, local and sports-keen audience. Email for rates and options.
An Australian basketball forum covering NBL, WNBL, ABL, Juniors plus NBA, WNBA, NZ, Europe, etc | Forum time is: 10:51 am, Fri 26 Apr 2024 | Posts: 968,026 | Last 7 days: 754
